Tested by Sweet dreams are made of exceptional bedding. That’s why each year, the Good Housekeeping Institute Textiles Lab puts hundreds of products to the test to find the best options for every budget, sleep need and style preference.
Our experts recently spent five months evaluating the 2024 Best Bedding Awards submissions firsthand. GH scientists even enlisted the help of over 300 sleep testers, who each used their assigned products for extended periods and allowed us to accumulate thousands of nights’ worth of testing data.
When it comes to Lab testing, our analysts evaluated aspects like durability, washability, performance and craftsmanship. At-home reviewers weighed in on aspects such as comfort, support, ease of use and more. Beyond that, GH home editors weighed in on decor and design. Winners were selected based on attributes like quality, innovation, convenience, style and value.
So without further ado, here are the winners of Good Housekeeping’s 2024 Best Bedding Awards — including bed frames, mattresses, mattress toppers, sheets, pillows, comforters and more — to help you upgrade your bed.
Though it comes at a fraction of the price of other bed frames, this steel model from Zinus delivers an elegant aesthetic and smart design features. It’s built for easy DIY setup, has a sturdy platform so you don’t need to use a box spring and offers 11 inches of under-bed clearance for storage. Choose black or white to match your bedroom.
LAB RESULTS: Our lifestyle editor called it “a great way to infuse a touch of vintage design into your bedroom,” noting that it had an antique feel while still looking modern enough to pair with any home style. Our home improvement expert was also a fan, saying it took under an hour to assemble: “The parts were clearly labeled, and I like that all the necessary tools were included in the packaging.” It was also praised by consumer testers for its appearance and for feeling surprisingly sturdy.
Touted as a “perfect” platform bed, Thuma’s frame and upholstered headboard are simple yet elevated. The setup is based on a Japanese technique whereby the pieces fit together like a puzzle — no tools are needed for setup. There are four neutral finish options for the wood, and the fabric covering the headboard can be removed and machine-laundered.
LAB RESULTS: The quality, appearance and ease of assembly were consistently highlighted by our testers. One textiles analyst who assembled it on her own couldn’t believe how easily the pieces clicked together, adding, “Out of all the furniture in my home, this bed frame is one of my favorite pieces because of its sturdy yet timeless design.” A consumer tester agreed, saying, “This is by far better than any of the many other bed frames I have slept on. I’ve never had a bed that’s more stable than this one.”
Burrow is best known for its semi-customizable sofas, and this bed offers the same easy ordering process: Choose your size, frame (with five options including wood and fabric), optional headboard, leg type (straight or tapered) and leg color. It ships in boxes for easy, tool-free setup — all pieces snap or screw into place. Even the slats connect to the frame so there isn’t any shifting.
LAB RESULTS: Both the upholstered fabric and the wood frames received high praise from our at-home testers. One called it a “10/10” and highlighted the easy-to-follow instructions, noting that it had taken her only about 20 minutes to assemble. The overall style was also a big hit; one analyst raved that it looked “gorgeous” in person, while consumer testers called it “luxurious,” “high-quality” and “well thought out.”
Jam-packed with features — including AI technology — Tempur-Pedic’s base has head and foot lifts, a built-in massager, relaxing sounds, adjustable lumbar support, a responsive snore detector that raises the head, sleep tracking and more. These features work together so you can have a fully immersive experience for winding down at night and receive insights and analytics to help improve your sleep quality.
LAB RESULTS: Testers found that it truly improved their sleep comfort. “It was nice to be able to prop the bed up a bit to make myself comfortable,” said one. “I also really like getting the sleep statistics each night.” Our analysts highlighted the tech features, and one said the lumbar support “felt life-changing” when used with mattresses that tended to sink in.
Hybrid mattresses that combine foam and coils can get pricey, but this one from Serta offers a fantastic value for under $1,000. It’s made up of six layers with pressure-relieving foam at the top and a zoned coil system underneath for ergonomic support. Choose from three firmness levels to best match your preference.
LAB RESULTS: Our sleep tester gave it perfect scores across the board, noting that it was both contouring and supportive. She even said it alleviated her chronic shoulder and back pain: “I no longer wake up feeling achy. I now wake up feeling refreshed.” Beyond that, it slept cool and offered good edge support.
An all-foam mattress with a medium firmness level, Nolah’s model is great for side sleepers and anyone with back pain because it helps take weight off of pressure points. It contains three layers of foam — one for pressure relief, one for responsiveness and one for support — all encased in a soft Tencel outer cover.
LAB RESULTS: We’ve had several testers tell us that it felt supportive and even provided relief for their back and hip discomforts. Our most recent tester said it felt more comfortable than other foam mattresses, especially because “the top is soft and fluffy and underneath there is support.”
Measuring a luxurious 14 inches high, this hybrid bed-in-a-box from Bear uses a coil system with five targeted zones to help keep your spine aligned. On top of that, it provides excellent pressure relief via its foam layers. It comes in soft, medium and firm, though none is too soft or too firm.
LAB RESULTS: This mattress consistently amazes consumer testers, who give it top marks. Our most recent tester told us that she looked forward to climbing into bed every night because of it. “It cured my neck and shoulder ache,” she added. “It also doesn'’t move when my husband gets in and out of bed. I love sleeping on it every night.”
Sleep Number’s adjustable mattress lets you choose your own firmness level on your side of the bed. And while adjustable beds are known to be expensive, this one offers an unbeatable price. It comes equipped with sensors that analyze your sleep and ensure that you stay at your preferred firmness setting all night.
LAB RESULTS: Our tester gave it top marks and called it an “extraordinary upgrade” from her previous innerspring mattress. Its adjustability was her favorite feature, but she also highlighted the edge support and appearance. The delivery team was patient and helpful throughout the setup process.
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe Cooling Mattress
Combining luxe hybrid construction with an added foam pillow-top layer, Brooklyn Bedding's 13" mattress offers a cloudlike feel without sacrificing support. It’s made with zoned coils, several layers of foam and a cooling cover, and it’s available in three firmness levels.
LAB REVIEW: A home analyst tried this for a month and claimed to be “seriously obsessed...I’ve never slept on a more comfortable mattress than this.” She highlighted the cool-to-the-touch cover and said it was “perfect for a hot sleeper like me.” Testers also loved the pillow-top, saying it was more substantial than ones on other boxed mattresses.
A revolutionary model for boxed mattresses, Helix’s newest offering is so substantial that it ships in two separate boxes for setup. It’s a whopping 16 inches deep and uses five foam layers, two microcoil layers, an eight-inch coil base with zoned lumbar support and a cooling foam pillow-top. Its medium firmness is especially great for side sleepers.
LAB RESULTS: A sleep tester described it as feeling “luxurious” and “premium” and said, “I like that this mattress is supportive to my body while also giving a bit of a plush feel.” Our mattress analyst said it left her “speechless” when she tried it: “The zoned support is very notable. The mattress provides extra support or cushioning in all the right places... I couldn’t get up from the bed because it just felt so comfortable.”
Standing apart from mattresses made with memory foam, Naturepedic’s luxury model utilizes latex that is both organic and resilient. It also includes cotton, wool and coils, and the entire model is GOTS-certified organic. There's a comfy pillow-top the layers are tufted by hand (i.e., there’s no synthetic glue holding it together).
LAB RESULTS: Our mattress pro described it as ”dreamy” and said, “It’s so plush and cloud-like, yet it holds its shape as you’d expect of latex.” Our sleep tester agreed, calling it “cushiony and soft” but “structured enough to keep you from sinking too far.” She added that it alleviated her back pain and that while she was traveling she “kept dreaming about being back home in the comfort of this mattress!”
This 14-inch mattress from Amerisleep is the softest in the brand’s assortment and is made up of four distinct foam layers, including a durable support base, a targeted support layer, a softness layer and a contouring surface. It’s all encased in a cooling outer cover, making it great for hot sleepers. And because it’s entirely foam, it’s also ideal for sleepers who use an adjustable base.
LAB RESULTS: During his review, our tester noted that it wasn’t too soft and that it lived up to its cooling claims. “It actually does keep me cool throughout the night, which is exactly what I was looking for,“ he said. Another perk: “It keeps its shape no matter where I lie or sit. I do not wake up sore due to a bad night of sleep…this is by far the best mattress I have ever slept on.”
If you prefer to shop in a store or want to set up your mattress the same day you buy it, this model from Sleepy’s by Sealy is available at Mattress Firm stores. It’s considered an innerspring, but it still has some memory foam for pressure relief and an overall medium firmness. Not to mention that its price is competitive compared with those of similar models on the market.
LAB RESULTS: It had good bounce during at-home tests, which is what you’d expect from an innerspring model. Our reviewer praised how easy it was to set up and called it a “game changer” for its cushioning pillow-top, adding, “I never felt any pressure on my hips or shoulders when lying on my side.” She noted that family members of hers also tried it out and “they all had nothing but high praise for its level of comfort.”
Tempur-Pedic’s foam is unlike any other on the market; instead of you're sinking in instantly, it slowly adapts to the shape of your body. As a result, it offers exceptional contouring and relief for pressure points and motion isolation so you won’t feel your sleeping partner move. A new upgraded version also includes a zoned layer to offer more ergonomic support. You can choose soft or firm, and there's white glove delivery for in-home setup.
LAB RESULTS: Our tester had previously tried the last version of this mattress and noted that his newer model felt more responsive, making it easier to move. “I can comfortably roll around on it,” she told us. She also gave it perfect scores for comfort, support and overall satisfaction and loved how it conformed to her body without her sinking in too much.
A protector is the easiest way to extend the life of your mattress, but you’ll want one that doesn’t affect comfort or sleep quality. Airley’s waterproof cover prevents damage from spills, allergens and everyday wear and tear, all while using a Tencel top layer for softness and breathability. Its side panels are stretchy to fit securely on mattresses.
LAB RESULTS: Sleep testers unanimously said it was quiet and undetectable under their sheets. They also agreed that it stayed in place and felt cool as they slept. One summarized her experience by saying, “I like that the mattress protector is comfortable and unnoticeable. I couldn’t feel it under the sheets, no plastic-y sounds when moving.”
Sijo’s mattress pad adds a subtle layer of softness to your bed without drastically changing the feel — plus, it has cooling capabilities thanks to its temperature-regulating fill. There’s also a discreet waterproof layer to help protect your mattress.
LAB RESULTS: It was easy to put on beds and testers said it felt comfortable. One user told us, “It fits the bed perfectly and does not shift around. It is quiet and light and easy to clean!” Several also noted its cooling effect, with one saying, “I sleep on my back and have hot flashes a lot. I felt when I was having a hot flash, it helped my back stay cooler.”
With two inches of memory foam to add ample comfort and pressure relief to your existing mattress, Nolah’s topper is a quick and easy way to upgrade the feel of your bed. The foam is encased in a cotton cover and it has wide elastic straps to keep it secure on mattresses ranging from 10 to 15 inches high.
LAB RESULTS: One reviewer told us, “It made my mattress ‘new’ again,” while another said, “The mattress topper added a level of comfort that is lacking in my mattress. It also helped with temperature control, which was a huge bonus.” All testers agreed that it was easy to secure to their beds.
Not only does this topper from Avocado enhance the feel of your bed, but it also uses organic materials including cotton as well as latex, which is more resilient than memory foam. It offers two heights (two and three inches) and two firmness levels (medium and plush).
LAB RESULTS: Our testers tried the two-inch plush version and unanimously said the difference was noticeable. “It completely transformed my firm mattress into a comfortable, supportive cloud,” said one. “I loved how easy it was to lay on the mattress. It didn’t shift at all, and I didn’t overheat while sleeping.”
Most mattress toppers are foam- or fiber-filled, but this three-inch option from Saatva has a unique construction that utilizes a layer of steel microcoils on the bottom for the responsiveness of an innerspring. It still has memory foam on top for comfort, and it has a cotton cover and elastic bands to help it stay in place.
LAB RESULTS: It earned perfect scores for overall satisfaction from all our sleep testers, who also noted that it increased support. One said, “I felt like I was sleeping on a new mattress,” while another told us, “It makes my bed feel super luxurious and it makes me not want to get up in the morning—in the best way!”
Soft & Smooth
This best-selling sheet set from Mellanni is a fan favorite thanks to its low cost and the exceptional softness of its microfiber fabric. Not to mention that it comes in dozens of colors and prints and a whopping 15 sizes (including variations with deep pockets) to fit all types of mattresses.
LAB RESULTS: We’ve been recommending this set for five years, and it continues to stand out as a top performer in consumer tests. This year’s reviewers gave it perfect scores for softness, comfort and overall satisfaction. One described the sheets as making it “feel like you are sleeping in a hotel bed in your own home,” while another said, “They remind me of hotel sheets and make the sleeping experience more luxurious.”
The Company Store Legends Hotel Supima Cotton Sateen Sheet Set
Made of Supima cotton (a premium variety grown in the U.S.) in a smooth sateen weave, The Company Store’s sheet set is elegant in both appearance and feel. It’s generously sized to fit tall mattresses and comes in over 15 colors to let you find your perfect shade.
LAB RESULTS: Among the softest sheet sets we’ve ever tested, this set felt smooth yet not slippery in consumer evaluations. One called the sheets the “perfect thickness” while another raved, “These sheets are fabulous for all-year use. They are soft, feel luxurious and look amazing.” Testers also loved how well they stayed put on their mattresses, and most reviewers said they couldn’t find a single thing they disliked about them.
Egyptian cotton fibers are longer and more uniform, allowing the sheet fabric to be softer and more durable. And while it’s hard to prove that a material is truly Egyptian cotton, this sateen set from California Design Den holds the Gold Seal of authenticity from the Cotton Egyptian Association. And at under $100, it offers great value.
LAB RESULTS: Consumer reviewers rated these softer than dozens of other sheets in a blind comparison test. They also earned high marks from sleep testers, who loved the sturdy elastic band on the bottom of the fitted sheet. One tester said, “These sheets are absolutely phenomenal! They are super soft and cozy, but crisp enough to feel cool on your skin.”
Not only is this set from West Elm responsibly produced — it’s made of 100% Tencel lyocell and comes from a Fair Trade–certified factory — but also it stands out for its ultrasmooth and lightweight feel. The set comes in 10 colors and can fit mattresses up to 16 inches deep.
LAB RESULTS: The smooth fabric resisted pilling even after our machine rubbed swatches together 1,000 times. It also earned exceptionally high softness scores in both blinded comparison tests and at-home sleep tests. “I really enjoy that the silkiness of the sheets make my bed feel more lush,” one tester told us, adding, “Visually they are very beautiful as well.” Another said, “Their silky nature makes my bed feel more expensive.”
Combining soft fabric with phase change technology, Slumber Cloud’s innovative set is designed to store and release body heat all night long. The material, a blend of Tencel lyocell and Outlast viscose, gives it a silky and breathable feel.
LAB RESULTS: It earned perfect scores for temperature regulation. Hot sleepers were especially amazed; one told us, “I tend to overheat when using sheets at night, however, these sheets have been keeping me extremely cool.” Another said, “These sheets are amazing. At no point did I wake up sweating or hot. Even on cold nights they didn’t feel too cold, either. They are perfect and keep my bed at a perfect temperature!” As a bonus, they were shrink-resistant in Lab tests.
Crisp & Airy
Made in Portugal with French flax fibers, The Citizenry’s sheet set is exceptionally soft yet still delivers the breathability and unique texture you’d expect from linen. It also comes in 12 stunning shades, each an elegant earthy hue. The brand even offers $3 swatches if you want to feel before you buy.
LAB RESULTS: Rated softer than other linen sheets we evaluated, these were loved by sleep testers, who said they only got softer with each wash. They were also shrink-resistant in our tests. One at-home reviewer told us,“I loved the feel of the sheets; they are so soft yet substantial and natural-feeling. I can’t wait to get in bed and don’t want to get out.” Another added, “I loved that the color and texture of the sheets give any bed a crisp, fresh appearance.”
Unlike some percale that can feel rough, Brooklinen’s organic cotton set combines this classic weave with a garment wash finish to help it achieve its softness. It also has smart design features like envelope closures on the pillowcases and a fitted sheet with “long” and “short” sides labeled.
LAB RESULTS: Our home editor calls these “a staple in my home” and notes, “They hold up well in the wash and get more comfy over time.” Consumer testers were also fans, saying that they felt both crisp and cool. One told us, “They make my bed feel like I’m sleeping in a five-star hotel.” Another raved, “I hate making the bed, but with these sheets, it was a breeze!” Beyond that, the fabric aced our Lab’s pilling resistance tests.
A soft percale weave with a lived-in look and feel, Coyuchi’s organic cotton goes through a special process to help achieve its signature crinkled finish. It holds plenty of sustainably oriented certifications, including Fair Trade, GOTS and more. As an added touch, it comes with a reusable fabric bag for storage.
LAB RESULTS: Compared to other percale sheets, a textiles analyst described these as feeling “a little softer and more broken-in rather than crisp, but they still feel nice and airy," adding, “They’re some of my favorite sheets.” Testers described them as “beautiful” and “cool” and said the fitted sheet was easy to make the bed with because of its labeled sides and wide elastic band.
Pottery Barn’s no-frills percale set comes only in white, yet it offers Italian craftsmanship that the brand describes as having “the crisp structure of a button-down shirt combined with a smooth, cool-to-the-touch feel.”
LAB RESULTS: These sheets earned perfect scores for pilling resistance in Lab tests along with perfect scores for comfort and satisfaction from our sleep testers, with one describing them as having a “smooth crispness.” Testers also said the quality felt superior to that of the sheets they had previously used; one noted, “They feel thicker, sturdier and crisper overall” and added, “The sheets feel crisp and fresh even after a week of sleeping on them!”
Cushiony yet supportive, Tuft & Needle’s solid foam pillow is designed to conform to your head and maintain its shape during the night. And though foam is known to trap heat, this pillow uses ventilated holes and cooling materials to help prevent overheating. The cost per pillow decreases if you buy a set of two.
LAB RESULTS: It lived up to its claims, keeping its shape in both Lab pressure tests and at-home sleep tests. It was especially loved by side sleepers, with one saying, “This pillow might be the most comfortable that I’ve ever slept on. It provides much-needed head and neck support without sacrificing softness.” Another noted, “It maintained a good temperature; I never overheated.”
Beckham Hotel Collection Bed Pillows
Amazon’s best-selling bed pillow is from Beckham Hotel Collection and offers a great value when purchased in a set of two. Its filling is made of down alternative and it comes with a cotton outer cover. It’s fully machine-washable so you can easily keep it clean.
LAB RESULTS: The fill felt plush yet supportive to many sleep testers, who also said it maintained its shape well throughout the night. One back and side sleeper said, “I liked the soft filling and that it molded to my head and neck when I lay down and kept my head at a comfortable angle.” Users also highlighted the luxe appearance of the outer fabric, and Textiles Lab analysts noted how nicely its shape fit inside a standard pillowcase.
Coop Sleep Goods The Original Pillow
If you’re not sure whether you need a foam pillow or a fiber one, this one from Coop Sleep Goods gives you both with a blend of foam clusters and down alternative fiberfill. The result is a combination of softness and support, and the fill is adjustable so you can add or remove stuffing until you achieve your perfect pillow height.
LAB RESULTS: Testers loved its adjustability and how nicely it conformed to their heads. One reviewer said, “I liked how squishy the pillow was while still being supportive.” Another tester who had a neck injury noted that it keeps her aligned and even said it helped alleviate her pain. She added, “When I go to bed, I look forward to sleeping on it as I know I will have a restful night’s sleep.”
Nothing matches the loftiness of real down, and this pillow from Downlite has a fill power of 600 and is certified by the Responsible Down Standard. It also has a unique pillow-in-a-pillow design, where the inner pillow has a medium firmness, the outer pillow has a soft density and when combined they provide an overall firm feel.
LAB RESULTS: Most testers preferred using the layers all together, but liked how they could turn it into two pillows in a pinch if, say, they had guests over. One tester noted that it felt more breathable than her memory foam pillow and said, “There’s an airiness to this pillow from the down that makes it feel light while at the same time super supportive.”
Layla’s fill is a blend of memory foam and kapok, a natural fiber that’s similar to cotton but much silkier. The result is a plush, moldable and supportive feel, and it’s adjustable so you can add or remove fill to your liking.
LAB RESULTS: It was loved by side, back and stomach sleepers. One tester said, “I love that I could adjust the pillow to the height that was most comfortable for me. It was perfect for me as a back and side sleeper, providing the right neck support in both positions.” It’s also a personal favorite of one of our textiles experts, who found that unlike other pillows, it wasn’t too high for stomach sleeping.
This luxurious and innovative pillow is made with a latex core that’s surrounded by Purple’s signature elastic grid material, which feels surprisingly soft and supportive at the same time. The grid’s open structure also helps it feel more breathable, and the moisture-wicking cover adds to the cooling effect.
LAB RESULTS: It kept its shape perfectly in our Lab’s tests, immediately bouncing back after we left weights on it for eight hours. Testers agreed that it kept them cool, and several even said it alleviated their neck pain. One told us, “My neck is much more aligned because the pillow is fluffy yet firm. I really felt the support.”
Using Slumber Cloud’s cooling technology in its cover, this pillow stores and releases body heat to keep you at a just-right temperature. It’s a hybrid design with down alternative and foam inserts that are both removable, and it has a zippered side gusset to help you get the right height.
LAB RESULTS: Our reviewers were amazed by its cooling capabilities, especially because it stayed cool all night, and they said it performed better than other cooling pillows they’d tried. One added, “After I put a pillowcase on this pillow, it was still cool.” It also felt soft yet supportive to testers, and it kept its shape well in Lab tests.
Most adjustable pillows have loose stuffing or flat layers, but Twilla’s works differently: It comes with 10 pods (which are like mini pillows filled with foam pieces) in the queen size. Its outer pillow has a down alternative fill and a Tencel fabric cover.
LAB RESULTS: It performed well in Lab tests and was a hit with sleep testers. One called it “the perfect middle ground between fluffy and supportive,” while another said, “You don’t feel the actual pods inside the pillow. It just feels like one solid pillow.” Users also told us that it was super easy to adjust (avoiding a common complaint about other adjustable styles) and they could shift the pods around to support their preferred alignment.
Comforters & Duvet Inserts
With a softness you have to feel to believe, Buffy’s popular comforter has a unique construction in which the down alternative fibers are spun into a fluffy, weblike fill. It also has a Tencel lyocell outer cover, which is smoother and quieter than cotton.
LAB RESULTS: This is the comforter most of our textiles analysts use year-round in their own homes thanks to its unmatched fluffiness and even fill distribution. Sleep testers also loved its feel, with one describing it as “plump and luxurious without being overly heavy.”
Coyuchi’s splurge-worthy cover stands out for its top-notch construction. It uses responsibly sourced 600-fill-power down for loftiness and warmth without the weight, while the cover is made from organic cotton fabric that is tightly woven to keep the down from poking out.
LAB RESULTS: The fill stayed evenly distributed in both Lab and at-home tests. Reviewers gave it perfect scores for comfort. “I never felt too hot or too cold using it,” said one tester. “It felt warm and cozy but still very breathable. This comforter also feels very soft, luxurious and fluffy.”
With a cold-to-the-touch performance fabric, Rest’s comforter offers unparalleled cooling for hot sleepers. Its silky-smooth outer fabric is moisture-wicking, and it’s especially lightweight and thin compared with other comforters.
LAB RESULTS: Our sleep testers unanimously gave it high scores, with one highlighting that it’s great for people who overheat yet still like the secure feeling of sleeping with a cover. “I never got warm, which is a major issue I have at night,” she noted. “It kept me at a great sleeping temperature.”
This extra-large comforter from PeachSkinSheets is designed to drape over the sides of your bed for a cozy look and feel. It has a microfiber cover with a down alternative fill, includes matching shams, and is available in more than 30 colors.
LAB RESULTS: Testers loved using it without a duvet cover because it was so comfortable. “It felt like I was enveloped in a cloud,” one noted. “It was so soft and warm. I felt relaxed as soon as I got into bed.” Our reviewers also praised its size, saying it stayed in place well on their beds.
Duvet Covers
Made from a blend of cotton and polyester with 37.5 technology (a performance material that helps regulate temperature), Luxome’s duvet cover delivers a soft, crisp and substantial material that can help prevent overheating.
LAB RESULTS: Our sleep testers noticed its cooling capabilities and appreciated the thickness of the fabric. “It has a nice sturdiness to it,” one said, “It feels luxurious.” Another noted, “The cooling fabric prevents sweating but isn’t too cold, so it can also be used in the winter months.”
With subtle yet stunning embroidery on a crisp white fabric, Crane & Canopy’s cover is made in Italy using Egyptian cotton for the ultimate luxury. Matching shams are also available to complete the look on your bed.
LAB RESULTS: Testers called it “gorgeous,” with one adding, “It adds a touch of elegance to the bed and ties everything together.” They also highlighted the quality of the fabric, saying it kept its shape and felt exceptionally comfortable and crisp. “It doesn’t look wrinkly on my bed either, which helps with the polished hotel bed look,” one added.
Double Stitch by Bedsure Cotton Tencel Lyocell Duvet Cover Set
For a soft yet substantial feel, Double Stitch by Bedsure blends silky Tencel lyocell with durable cotton fibers so you get the best of both materials. It comes in four neutral colors and includes shams for a great value.
LAB RESULTS: It earned perfect scores for softness, comfort and overall satisfaction, but testers also highlighted its convenience. One noted, “It has fabric that covers the button closures at the end cover, so you don’t really see the buttons,” while another said, “My dog’s hair doesn't seem to stick in the fabric at all.”
Piglet in Bed’s European flax cover adds a relaxed yet beautiful look with its textured linen fabric. It’s prewashed for added softness and comes in a wide range of bold and muted hues to match any color preference. For an added touch, the button closures are made from coconut shells.
LAB RESULTS: The fabric was pill-resistant in Lab tests and a textiles analyst that has used it for two years confirmed that it's held up well. Sleep testers raved that it felt cool and comfortable. “I really like the look and texture,” one added. “The duvet cover gives my bedding set a bit more of a cozy, clean look.”
Quilts & Coverlets
Soft and lightweight with a decorative striped texture, Brooklinen’s cotton set includes a quilt and two shams. It can be used on its own in warmer weather or as an added layer in cooler months.
LAB RESULTS: Testers liked that it was thick and plush without feeling too heavy. “The fabric is very soft and breathable,” added a textiles analyst. “It looks better than other quilts I’ve owned and gives my bed a relaxed, put-together look.”
Grandin Road’s textured cover is made of 100% cotton (including the fill) with a hand-stitched design. You can buy it on its own, but matching pillow covers are also available.
LAB RESULTS: Testers highlighted the subtle pattern, substantial thickness and overall comfort of the cover, noting that the fabric felt smooth and luxurious. One added, “The material is soft and almost cushion-like.”
Using a French flax linen with a down alternative fill, The Citizenry’s quilt has a simple box-stitch construction for even distribution. It comes in over a dozen neutral colors and prints.
LAB RESULTS: A tester described it as “the perfect middle weight between a duvet and a thin blanket,” and added, “this is really one of the most comfortable and stylish quilts I have seen.” Users also loved its softness.
This affordable coverlet and sham set from Mellanni uses a soft microfiber fabric and a pinsonic quilting technique, meaning the layers are fused together so you don’t need to worry about stitches unraveling.
LAB RESULTS: A GH home editor tried it out and said she was impressed by its quality for the price. She also noted that it was light, but versatile enough for layering in colder months, “I can see this being used for decorative purposes.”
Blankets
American Blossom Linens Herringbone Weave Cotton Blanket
Made in America using 100% cotton, this classic blanket from American Blossom Linens has a subtle yet sophisticated twill weave. It comes in four sizes (including throw) and is designed for year-round use.
LAB RESULTS: Testers said it felt soft and cozy to sleep with, yet didn’t cause them to overheat. “It’s also beautiful!” raved one, “I love the herringbone design and the color.” An analyst also noted that it folded down nicely for storage.
Boll & Branch’s blanket is made of soft organic cotton in a springy waffle weave, which helps it achieve a plush yet lightweight feel. The fabric is also preshrunk and has an oversize fit to layer on beds.
LAB RESULTS: Testers enjoyed its softness and breathability. One said, “the waffle texture is nice and comfortable.” They also loved the look, with one analyst noting that it adds visual texture to an otherwise smooth-looking bed.
The solution to cold toes poking out under blankets, Lovesac’s innovative style has a subtle yet smart pocket at the bottom to tuck feet inside. It’s made of a cozy faux fur fabric and comes in plenty of color options, plus two sizes designed for both individual use and sharing.
LAB RESULTS: It was a hit with textile analysts, with one calling it “simple yet genius." The fabric felt indulgent and soft and it was versatile for using on beds and sofas while lounging, taking naps and watching movies.”
Not only is Bedsure’s blanket incredibly comfy with a velvety top and a sherpa underneath, but it also has built-in heating capabilities for added warmth. Its attached control offers six heat levels and two time settings.
LAB RESULTS: Analysts and testers all noted that it heated up quickly and had even distribution. “Even without using the heating function, the blanket is perfect for taking a nap,” said one tester. “I enjoyed using it both as a blanket and as a heated blanket.”
Designed to provide gentle pressure for relaxation, Luna checks off the boxes for a quality weighted blanket thanks to its cotton cover, dense glass beads and quilted construction for even distribution. It's available in 15 or 20 pound weights; aim for roughly 10% of your body weight.
LAB RESULTS: “I found myself more relaxed more quickly,” said one tester. “It was easier to fall asleep faster.” Another noted that although some weighted blankets can be an eyesore, “I really liked that this blanket looks like a quilt.”
Ideal for settling down at night or wearing when you wake up in the morning, Bedsure’s blanket has a hood and sleeves to keep you fully covered as you move. It has a soft flannel exterior and a cozy sherpa lining, plus it’s available in various colors and sizes for the whole family.
LAB RESULTS: One of our textile pros swears by it, saying it’s roomy and warm but not overwhelming to wear. “It’s so soft and comfortable,” she added. “The material holds up well with use.” Testers also liked the softness and fit, saying it stays in place better than a robe.
Helping to keep your entire body aligned as you sleep, Buffy’s extra-long pillow is flexible to add support wherever you need it. It’s made with a soft lyocell outer cover and a fluffy yet squishy polyester fill that’s made from recycled water bottles.
LAB RESULTS: Our reviewers and Lab experts all loved the length. “I can hug it and rest my head against it while having it support my knees and lower body,” one tester said. Another added, “It allows for quite a lot of flexibility in terms of the different positions.” Analysts also noted that it was easy to bend, allowing you to tie it in knot for a decorative look when you're not using it.
This stuffed animal from Bearaby is made specifically to help adults feel calm. It’s available in three varieties (bear, elephant and rabbit), each made of crocheted cotton and weighted clay in the bodies to promote relaxation. They also have an extended paw for more coverage.
LAB RESULTS: Testers loved its comfort and quality, while analysts appreciated that it kept its shape, washed well and had a grown-up aesthetic. “It feels relaxing to snuggle next to it at night and helps create a restful environment before going to sleep,” said one. “It’s also nice to hold when reading or relaxing before bed to ease anxiety.”
The silk fabric used in Brooklinen’s pillowcase and eye mask feels refreshing to lie on, plus its smooth fabric helps prevent bedhead and skin creases by reducing friction as you toss and turn. You can purchase these items individually or mix and match the colors in your bundle.
LAB RESULTS: Testers with a range of skin and hair types rated it smooth, cool and comfortable. They also noticed that it prevented facial creases and liked its quality construction, including the thickness and case closure to prevent the pillow from slipping out. “I love that they are machine washable!” added one. “That makes all the difference.”
Protecting hair while you sleep, Clementine Sleepwear’s bonnet is made of mulberry silk for a smooth and comfy surface. It has a substantial 22 momme weight and an adjustable strap to help you get the right fit.
LAB RESULTS: Testers liked it better than other bonnets they’d tried and said it was comfortable, stayed in place and reduced tangles and frizz. “I was impressed that I was able to loosen and tighten it for a better fit,” said one. “The material is light and silky smooth, and the wrap doesn’t feel heavy on my head.”
Lexie Sachs (she/her) is the executive director of strategy and operations at the Good Housekeeping Institute and a lead reviewer of products in the bedding, travel, lifestyle, home furnishings and apparel spaces. She has over 15 years of experience in the consumer products industry and a degree in fiber science from Cornell University. Lexie serves as an expert source both within Good Housekeeping and other media outlets, regularly appearing on national broadcast TV segments. Prior to joining GH in 2013, Lexie worked in merchandising and product development in the fashion and home industries.
